I got an intimidating email in my in-box the other day. It was from Colby Sharp asking if I was interested in writing for the Nerdy Book Club blog. Now I had signed up to be considered for the guest blogging role, so I knew I might get tapped, but still being asked to write for a blog and community that I have always just lurked near was daunting.
I was asked to write a post for the tag “Pay it Forward.” I’m still not sure exactly want that means so I have spent the last few days thinking of how I would respond. My first thought went to my work with SMS Guys Read, a reading club I started nearly six years ago to champion boys reading and highlight the books that appeal to guys. I love working with my guys read club, but a digital friend of mine, Mr. Shaffer wrote both eloquently and elaborately on the subject of Guys Read and even gave our club and our Intercontinental Ballistic Reading Group a cool shout out.
So what was I to write about? After looking back over some older posts and thinking about what else I manage to do in the reading lives of my students and school I have decided to talk about my AFFL group. Even now, nearly a year since its inception that joke still gets me smiling… my AFFL (pronounced awful) reading group. Still funny.
So let me go back to the beginning and set the stage for you. I teach sixth grade social studies on an interdisciplinary team of four teachers. We teach the classic four core subjects of Language Arts, Science, Math and Social Studies. Even though I am the social studies teacher and not the traditional reading teacher, my love for children’s literature has pushed me to become more of a champion for reading on our team. I have pushed, I will say without much resistance, for the role of reading to be a shared responsibility and not just the focus of our language arts teacher on our team. We now each take a day of the week to have silent free reading session and do with the students what we will. That means that students on our team will have SSR in Math, LA, Science and SS once each week. It is now so ingrained in the minds of our teachers that we look forward to our SSR day as much as the students, sometimes maybe even more.
We also used this sharing of responsibility and the focus on championing reading from lots of points of view to the area of circulation and the media center. Normally the Language Arts teacher is the only instructor allowed in the media center for student’s circulation time. We decided to share the responsibility between the science and social studies teachers. Now both my science colleague and I had once taught language arts so we both felt comfortable in the role of sharing books, and wanted our student the experience to hear our thoughts on books and reading as well.
My science colleague is an old friend and we have playfully disagreed on my subjects over our teacher careers, but after we jumped head first into reading we found we had one gigantic reading difference. I told a student they should read Percy Jackson and The Lighting Thief, My science buddy over heard this advice and thought he might need to see what all the Percy Jackson fuss was about. He read the book and hated it. In fact he decided right then and there that he hated all fantasy books and went about telling any sixth grader within ear shot how bad fantasy stories were. The battle lines on our team started to form.
This became a year of banter back and forth between us, him championing nonfiction and me championing fantasy. After one relatively heated confrontation about Colin Meloy’s Wildwood, I decided I need to something more than banter; I had to band all of our fantasy loving students together, so I formed the AFFL reading group. AFFL stands for the Anti F(our fantasy loathing teacher’s last name starts with F) Fantasy League. Our role was to champion fantasy reading and blow razz-berries and anyone who claimed fantasy was silly or dumb.
We started meeting once a week during our school’s enrichment time and started out reading Colin Meloy’s Wildwood. After reading and meeting for a few weeks, we actually decided that this was more than just a one off club and we need to become more of a permanent group. We then created a blog and started meeting regularly at lunch.
After Wildwood, we started reading the Unwanteds by Lisa McMann and started making videos to go along with our readings. Those videos were the highlight of our time together and really probably one of the reasons so many students kept coming around, even if that meant not eating in the lunch room with the other students.
After a few videos, my flip camera started to die. The video sound kept coming out all fuzzy and I made a half joking comment asking if anyone would like to donate a new camera. Lisa McMann saw our videos about her book and responded that she would be willing to share a camera with us as well as some really fantastic sway from her great Unwanteds book. My AFFL students were over the moon. Not only had the author of this book we loved written to us, but she loved what we were doing and was willing to share cool stuff with us. Powerful!
We even asked Lisa McMann what we should read after The Unwanteds. She demanded (her words) that we read The False Prince by Jennifer Nielsen. After reading some of The False Prince and making more fun and fantastic videos Ms. Nielsen saw what we were up to and wrote us a very kind and incredibly powerful letter, she included with the letter some stones to go along with the plot of her fantastic story and some autographed stickers.
Three books read and two very powerful reading experiences met. We finished The False Prince right as our school year was ending, but we living the slightly strange world of year-round schools, so the end of last year was the end of June and we have already been back to school for about three weeks. As I see my now 7th grade AFFL members in the hallways they ask continually what is up with AFFL? So this school year we have made AFFL a legit after school club meeting twice a month. Our first meeting was last week and it was almost like a family reunion, even though we had only been gone a few weeks.
We have an author visit from Kenneth Oppel happening at the end of the month so AFFL will be reading his Silverwing novel and hopefully having a grand conversation with him and maybe some local bat experts. T-shirts are being planned and the members of AFFL are just as committed and excited about our group as they were when it first formed. In fact I now have to decide what to do with this year’s group of 6th graders. The word is out there that we have this AFFL reading group for students who love fantasy and current 6th graders are starting to ask me, “When can I join AFFL?” I think this AFFL group might have legs.
So what is my point in all of this rambling, really I think it boils down to championing reading wherever you can. Finding a hook and running with it. I have found that middle school students crave the club setting and if structure the club around books and reading you can be successful with students.
I am lucky to teach in a school and on a team that love to read. I am lucky to have a friend who can push me on my love of fantasy and then handle me pushing back with a club named in his honor. I am truly honored to work with groups of students who love to read and are willing to give up their personal free time to meet with me and talk about books.







What a great post- the collegiality and joy at your school makes me envious!
This is fantastic! I love the organic evolution of the after school club. There are so many wonderful facets involved here. I hope the science teacher appreciates fantasy a little more now (*wink*), and is inspired to discover a similar way to champion non-fiction.
Story creates powerful connections…have to admit I cried a little when you got to the parts about authors reaching out to your group. Good stuff! And lol on how it all started. With one of my personal favorites…WILDWOOD. Man, I love that book. Way to pay it forward!
Great post! Books are for reading AND debating and I love that you built that right into your club. And THE UNWANTEDS & THE FALSE PRINCE are among my favorite books (I have yet to read WILDWOOD, but just added it to my stack).
Great article! I’m glad to see you jumping into a #nerdybookclub post. You do so many wonderful things with your students. I’m excited that you got to share them.
Can’t wait to start this year’s IBRG! My group is just starting to sign up, so I’ll be in touch!
Keep up the great work!
First off, I agree with everyone’s comments. As an English/Social Studies teacher and a children’s bookseller, this blog just makes me happy and I can’t wait to share it.
Secondly, I loved reading about Lisa McMann and Jennifer Nielsen. Jennifer Nielsen spoke last year at the SCIBA Children’s Books & Literacy Dinner in February (2012). Lisa McMann just happened to be there as well signing books.It’s awesome to hear that Lisa is recommending Jennifer’s book.
Finally, A new book out is Keeper of the Lost Cities. My students who have read Percy Jackson, The Unwanteds, are reading this book, and enjoying it very much. The author is Shannon Messenger who is a delightful young lady. This is her first book, and is thrilled to be a published author.
I am looking forward to reading your AFFL blog. I’m always looking for excellent book suggestions. Keep up the awesome work!
Hey Hutch,
First, great post….but shouldn’t the “Ferriter” in the “Anti-Ferriter Fantasy League” get some kind of say in all of this?!
Seriously, what I love the most — and one of the things that I think the kids dig — about AFFL is the back-and-forth banter (read: arguments) between all of us about the merits of fantasy and non-fiction.
I think that’s right up the alley of most middle schoolers who are still trying to figure out who they are — and more importantly, who they want to be. Are they “Hutch Kids” or “Ferriter Kids?” Are they “Fantasy Fans” or “Non-Fiction Fans?” Are they “Gryffindors” or “Slytherins?”
AFFL becomes an identity. A place to belong. So does the Anti-AFFL-Nonfiction-Lovers-League. (AAFFLNFLL. New club. Pronounced Ah-Awful-Nah-Filafel in case you were wondering. Starting it on Monday. And we’re making t-shirts, too.)
That’s cool. That’s what we do well. More importantly, that’s why I still love teaching with you after 13 years.
#crazy
Now to the Lightening Thief: It’s HORRIBLE. 10 pages of exciting followed by 300 pages of boring followed by 5 pages of exciting. Come on, Hutch: They’re DEMI-GODS and they have to take a Greyhound, an Amtrak and a moving van — full of rescued circus animals, no less — to California?!
#evencrazier
And as for Wildwood: It’s the most frustrating book I’ve read in the past year. I’d get into a real groove with the cool battle scenes and then be hit square in the face by a wall of stupid. Seriously: Sheet-wearing hippies asking a tree for permission to start a war? Come ON.
#fantasyisaffl
(Wait. That’s the point, isn’t it?!)
Rock right on,
Bill
PS: You have a BLOG named after me, too?!?!?
PPS: Have you read MY post on nonfiction yet? http://smartblogs.com/education/2012/09/06/reading-nonfiction-not-optional/
#takethat
As a memeber of AFFL I would like to thank Mr. Hutchinson for starting this awesome/amazing club. No offense Mr. Ferriter but I am not sure how AAFFLNFF is going to work out. I think that AFFL is an awesome opportunity for all of the fantasy members who joined in to have an awesome time reading fantasy and being fantasy geeks! I hope to continue in the AFFL tradition of reading fantasy. Are any of you other nerdy bloggers willing to round up some AFFL students and create your own AFFL club? That would sure show you Mr. Ferriter! Fantasy rocks!
#takethatMr.Ferriter
Hello Im AFFL. I have really enjoyed the shenanigans that we have done the videos were very fun. I have been in 3 book clubs all at the same. I really enjoy reading. #AFFL
I love AFFL, in AFFL we read a bunch of fantasy books. Then sometimes we get to talk with the author through mr.H’s twitter. Plus the authors sometimes give us book suggestions. We actually got to meet one of them like Kenneth Oppel. When i go to high school i will miss being AFFL, but i will forever be on the Fantasy side of life.
I am an AFFL member and have been one since day 2. Not day 1, day 2. I remember reading Wildwood aloud with Mr. H. and the others. It was kind of boring, so I was glad when we moved on to taking books home and doing things with them. When we started The Unwanteds, I was very exited since I had already read it and got to read it again. We did so many things and had SO much fun I HAD to stay. I’ve loved the group ever since and hope to do it again in 8th grade. Have an AFFL day!!!!
Rainbow Dirt the AFFL
I really like that you came up with AFFL. Unlike Mr.F, I love reading fantasy! AFFL let’s me express myself in a different way. When we meet we talk about what Mr.H blogged (on our blog) and do some kind of video. I think that AFFL is a great club and is, as we AFFL people say, is very AFFL.
#AFFLrocks
hi,
I’m a an AFFL student. i think this club is awsome! we are kind of small but still have fun since we all are carzy about fantasy! this club is cool since we get to read awsome books and chat about them with a totally amazingly teacher. Mr. Huthchison did not mention that we in the very begining we were a bunch of Harry Potter nerds, looking for more great reads.oh and Mr. Ferriter, Fantasy rocks and is that atcually gonna be a club?
keep on reading fantasy and being AFFl!
Rachel
Hi, i am caden (as you probably know by know). I am AFFL and awful so… The reason i always come is because all my freinds did it so i thought it may be fun. My favorite moment was when i played my fippler during the fippler challenge and even had my own nose solo. #why you ackin so cray cray ferriter
I a, kind of upset that you didnt write about Guys Read. (a member)
I DO NOT AGREE with Mr. Ferriter though at all, the reason I’m “AFFL”. Oh, and any other kids reading this READ Fantasy NOT NON-FICTION. Gosh Mr. Ferriter!!!
Hello everyone.
First of all, dont be discorage by Mr.F Hatefullness. He said he Loved Wildwood for the most part. He told me that he loved the characters. Yes he loved a fantasy book. It started when We were intrested in pottermore. We than started with the Super Secret book club. I quited than. I returned when we started reading The unwanteds. We wanted to get the writer of affl to contact us but we faild. I have loved affl so much. We have made new book friends like Alex, Goth, Matt Cruse, and many more. I have loved affl everytime I get a chance to go. I want it to meet more often so I get to see my affl buddies and get to fight the power agianst Mr.Ferriters nonfiction. This has been a once and a life time experience that I will never forget. I have loved this club and will be a member for life.
Some people might say “I’m affl and i know it!”