They’re called Icebreakers. You know the questions designed to break the ice in a conversation, like what famous person living or dead would you like to have dinner with? Or if you could time travel, when would you go? Another one is, if you were stranded on a desert island, what one book would you like to have with you? Well, imagining myself on a desert island while doing an icebreaker kind of presents a clash of terms and pulls me out of the narrative I’m trying to create in my head. So, being the writer that I am, I respond to the question with some initial revisions.
First of all, I’d rather not be on a desert island, so I’ll backspace that out of there and type in porch swing. If I was stranded on a porch swing, what one book would I like to have with me? While I’m revising, let’s go ahead and add that I have an ice-cold glass of lemonade in hand and it’s a cool afternoon in June—before the mosquitos have come out.
There, now we’re getting somewhere. So, what book would I pick? Toughie. The answer might vary on any given day. I could pick Lord of the Rings because it’s a great story and I’d really be getting three books instead of just one. I could pick the Bible. I’d get a whole bunch of books in that one! Hmm, I need to give it more thought.
In the meantime, let’s go back to the question about what person living or dead would you like to have dinner with and change that one to what person would you like to be stranded on the porch swing with? Any good porch swing is at least a two-seater. So maybe I’d invite the author Eudora Welty, because I visited her home this summer and she seems like a person I’d really like. Plus, she’s from the south so she would probably enjoy a good porch swing. But if Eudora’s coming, maybe I should pick one of her books. I’d love to hear her talk about her book on writing, One Writer’s Beginnings. That would be a great icebreaker. We’d have all kinds of things to talk about. Things are looking good on the porch swing. Eudora is a talker and she has a great Mississippi accent.
Now we might as well bring in the time travel question as well, so I would time travel with Eudora Welty on the porch swing to a typical day back in the 1940’s – before television and an overabundance of technology. Perfect for porch swinging. Unfortunately, Eudora decided to go home because she missed air-conditioning.
So here I am again, stranded by myself on that porch swing. Still without a book to claim as my one book. But I do have a pen. And a notebook. With lots of blank pages. And I’ve already been wandering down an imaginative path with these hypothetical questions. For me, that’s where all of my stories begin. With a lot of questions and a healthy dose of imagination. So, I guess my answer is, I’d stick with the blank notebook as my one book. I would have countless stories to explore and a variety of characters to accompany on their journeys.
Definitely, a blank book. It’s not so bad being stranded on a porch swing.
CLARE VANDERPOOL lives in Wichita, Kansas, with her husband and their four children. She is the author of the 2011 Newbery Medal-winning novel, Moon Over Manifest. Today is the book birthday for her second novel Navigating Early, an extraordinary adventure of two boys’ quest for buried secrets on the Appalachian Trail. Learn more at ClareVanderpool.com.









excellent response to those questions!!
Love this line of thought. I’d like to be on that porch swing myself – with a glass of tea and a notebook to write in.
I love the way you think! Now who would I like to visit with on my porch swing. Definitely something to think about but since I am always intrigued by authors and how they get their ideas. So I guess any author would be great. Are you up for it when I get my porch swing?
Great post! I LOVED Moon Over Manifest and look forward to reading Navigating Early very soon. I have heard such great things about it already.
Oh I have always hated those questions but I love the back space to the porch swing and a blank book for writing. Yes to tea, summer sun and gentle breezes.
( a great post to read on a cold day in Minnesota winter).
Thanks for your enjoyable post. I love the idea of you revising the question as you go. I might have to have my students try that in their own writing.
While at my local Dillons grocery store I saw a display of Navigating Early. Then I read this post. I was hooked by the voice in your writing and knew I had to go back to the store to by your book. Doubly cool is that it is written by a fellow Kansan.
Nice post. I’ve always hated those type of soulless questions. I loved, loved Navigating Early! It truly touched my heart. It was my desire to have my review up before the book release, but I wanted to make sure I had the right words. I hope I’ve done it justice in my review.
http://whatstheword-saywhaaat.blogspot.com/2013/02/navigating-early.html