Tags
All You Need Is Love by Donalyn Miller
Cindy Minnich, one-third of the Nerdy facilitator team, spent a whirlwind week at BEA and picked up our Independent Book Bloggers Award. We are thrilled that Nerdy won this award and we share it with every reader and poster of this blog.
Chatting during a recent conference call, Cindy regaled Colby and me with tales about her BEA trip. She was entranced by publishers and publicists talking about their favorite upcoming titles at their booths and the Editors’ buzz sessions, and tickled pink to meet some of the authors she and the rest of Nerdy Nation have enjoyed so much. She met some friendly folks who wore blogger badges, too.
Unfortunately, the poor behavior exhibited by some bloggers rattled Cindy—the casual way they talked to her about leaving advance reader copies (ARCs) behind because it costs too much to get them home or their descriptions of tossing ARCs when they are done with them. She saw several bloggers leave the Editors’ Sessions early—apparently to get closer to the table of ARCs, so they could snag at least one copy of each.
Reading the tweets and blog posts about bloggers storming the American Library Association Conference’s exhibit hall to snatch free ARCs last week doesn’t put book bloggers in a good light, either. I like to imagine that every one of those ARCs will be passed into the hands of a reader who needs a book. I like to imagine that people dragging six overflowing bags behind them are librarians and teachers who spent thousands of dollars of their own money on books last year. I like to imagine that these ARCs will never show up on e-Bay.
I like to imagine quite a bit, but I read a lot of fiction and spend most of my time with children.
As a follow-up to our IBBA Award win, we were asked in an interview to comment on Nerdy’s influence in selling books. We can honestly say that we don’t know and we don’t think about it. The only bookselling we care about on Nerdy is hand-selling Hatchet to Bobby in third period.
The Nerdy Book Club blog is not specifically a book review blog, although we post reviews here. The Nerdy Book Club blog is a readers’ blog—particularly young readers and the teachers, school and public librarians, authors, parents, and other folks who promote books and reading to kids. Nerdy is a place for readers. I hope many readers have found a home here. We love kids, reading, and books. We love anyone who loves these things, too. That’s all Nerdy is.
As for our friends in the publishing industry, we appreciate you. Let’s be clear. We appreciate you because we need you to continue to publish quality books for our children and engage them with reading. We believe that reading is art appreciation. We need your art. T-shirts and bookmarks and plush dolls are fun, but they don’t entice us to promote your books over others. It’s not about the swag. It’s about the stories.
Colby, Cindy, and I have always had a policy about promotions, advertising, and reviews. We think it is a good time to share our policy with the rest of you.
We do not accept unsolicited books for review. Please do not email us asking us to review your newest book. We do not want to feel obligated to review your book just because you sent us a copy.
All reviews are positive. If we can’t say something nice about a book on Nerdy, we don’t review it. We do not feel the need to show off our intelligence by writing an 800 word review about how terrible a book is.
Books reviewed exemplify engaging literature for children. Our definition of quality may not match yours. We care about kid appeal. The kids do, too.
No book will be reviewed solely because of a relationship with publishers or authors. All authors who post on Nerdy are invited to post. No one provides incentives to Nerdy facilitators in exchange for posting.
Any ARCs received for review ultimately wind up in the hands of kids. Cindy, Colby, and I are classroom teachers, and most of Nerdy’s bloggers work in libraries and schools. Our ARCs go to classrooms and libraries. If you need a place to donate your ARCs, consider enrolling in the ARCs Float On program, run by Sarah Mulhern Gross.
Nerdy will never attempt to make a profit. We do not post ads. We do not sell products or programs. We will not approve your post or comment if you do. We are currently reviewing every blogger on the Nerdy blog roll, and we will remove any for-profit bloggers.
As a teacher, I gut check every decision by asking, “What is the right thing for the kids?” I think this ideal has been a good compass for Nerdy Book Club, too. Any blog dedicated to elevating young adult and children’s literature should be about the kids. As long as Nerdy Book Club continues to celebrate children and their books, we can’t go wrong.
** A note about the Nerdy Book Club store and the Indie Bound link. We do have a Nerdy Book Club store where you can buy your own Nerdy swag (insert irony button here). We donate the tiny profits from this store to Reading Is Fundamental. We earn about $30 a month. No one has used the Indie Bound link as far as we can tell. Let’s consider it a “Buy Indie” badge.
Donalyn Miller is a fourth grade teacher at Peterson Elementary in Fort Worth, TX. She is the author of The Book Whisperer: Awakening the Inner Reader in Every Child. Donalyn co-hosts the monthly Twitter chat, #titletalk (with Nerdy co-founder, Colby Sharp), and facilitates the Twitter reading initiative, #bookaday.
Well said and much needed. I love how you walk your talk, Donalyn. If we, as teachers and librarians, worry about giving kids books for a test they will take or because they are selling well, we take away the purposeful path we all share in helping them be lifelong learners.
I am on the Board of our local public library. We hold a book sale every year. It is a gold mine for my classroom. But, I loath the people in the book fair with their scanners trying to figure out what they can sell on ebay. We are desperately trying to get books in the hands of people who need them and to support our library. We don’t need people profiting off of us.
Thanks for articulating the Nerdy Book Club mission and intent (Love the “hand selling” to students of books that would be just right for them). I think it is important that it become clear that the site is for love of books, not advertising for vendors. Let’s keep that love alive!
Kevin
Thanks for making the NBC mission clear for all. As for myself, what this group has provided is a home. As a lifelong NBC member I never really knew that there were others like me. Yes, my parents are BIG readers and were big influences on my start, but the need I have to help kids find GREAT books is such a part of who I am as a teacher. When I was married, my ex said we should just sign my check over to Scholastic, as I spent so much each month when the new catalogs came out. As a single mom my budget is tighter, and my older son can not fathom why I do not travel much, but I do… it is just in the pages of books. I appreciate knowing that there are others who feel just as passionately as I do and I LOVE reading about all of the great books that I must read and pass on to the students I know. I am jealous that some have access to ARCs, etc., but I am also grateful that the NBC people who do, pay it forward by turning the rest of us on to the #Wonderofwonder, #Theoneandonlyivan, #Martymcguire, #Oneforthemurphys, #Babymouse, and so many more great books that I have bought, read, and passed on, thanks to you! “What is the right thing for the kids?” is a great guiding question.
Thank you all!
Erika
Yes! Exactly! I’ve linked back to your post from my ‘About Me’ page on BooksYALove, since y’all articulated here precisely what I was trying to say in my recent post on ARCs and recommending books for YA readers.
Power to NBClub, getting the right book to the right reader! (Ranganathan is still right).
I admire the integrity of your policy about promotions. Thanks for posting that. It gives every blogger something to think about!
Love this post and The Nerdy Book Club. 🙂
Excellent post, and as a commenter above commented, it needed to be said. Not all blogs and bloggers are the same, and I’ve always admired the way that Nerdy Book Club puts young readers before anything else. Swag, ARCs, etc are all nice, but what really matters is that the reader finds the book she/he needs.
Bravo! It boggles my mind how often the same thing needs to be said, but I admire that you say it so eloquently. Those of us who love kids first, then their books need to keep searching for the right book for the right kid at the right time….bah, humbug to those who see ARCs and conferences as a means to fill their totes and tout sales, not stories. Thank you, Donalyn.
“I like to imagine quite a bit, but I read a lot of fiction and spend most of my time with children.”
You guys are the best. I love you. That is all.
Well said.
Hello! Wonderful post.
I just want you to know that I teach 7th grade, and whenever I receive an ARC, I read it first, and then send it on its way to another teacher (if it’s not appropriate for my grade), or right into the hands of students. Yes, some of us are dreamers, and do the right thing. Keep the glass half-full, and maybe your dreams will come true!
-@JoyKirr
Hurrah and long live the Nerdy Book Club.
Brava!
There is magic in the way you are able to take some of the negativity Cindy witnessed and turn it in to a grounded, yet uplifting reminder of why we all do what we do: to hand-sell Hatchet to Bobby in third period.
I have to confess that I have purchased a few stacks of books as a result of what I’ve read here, and although I didn’t use the Indie Bound button, I did visit the nearest Indie Bound bookseller I know and love. So, publishers can rest assured that your mission to put quality literature in the hands of students (in my case 8th graders) does indeed put money in their pockets–for the right reasons.
I think it’s all been said, & said well in the comments above, but here’s a thank you, Donalynn for what’s the most important to me, “What is the right thing for the kids?”. You’ve written the philosophy so well, and I appreciate your words very much.
Preach it! xoxo
Well put, my friend. I love this line:
Nerdy is hand-selling Hatchet to Bobby in third period.
And this:
I like to imagine that people dragging six overflowing bags behind them are librarians and teachers who spent thousands of dollars of their own money on books last year.
Cheers to buying books — no matter what!
This post makes my heart smile…everything about it. The mission of this site and your candor are both appreciated!