Tags
Top Ten Old-School Girl Books by Lyn Fairchild Hawks
I write YA novels about gifted, weird, wise girls – GWW girls for short . Nerd nation gals, the dork divas, the geek chicks. I’ve always felt the magnetic pull to stories about girls who didn’t fit, who chose the path of most resistance, who see the way clear to solving problems no one else attempts, who instigate annoyance, and who thrive on creativity. Here’s my top ten list of old-school books about old-school girls, what one might call the YA of the 20th century before we called it YA.
This is a hard list to narrow, and I truly hated abandoning certain gifted, weird, wise girls for a short list of ten. You may well ask, You left out Meg in A Wrinkle in Time? I plead for forgiveness up front, as I had to err on the side of personal taste when making the tough choices. (Physics fries my brain—sorry, Ms. L’Engle!)
My main criteria: a) Does the book star a gifted, weird, wise girl?; b) Did the book beguile me as a teen or preteen?; and c) Does the book raise tough issues or lead to strange high jinks? Because GWW girls can handle both.
-
GWW girls have a “besetting sin,” known as “imagining too much.” Anne Shirley of Anne of Green Gables by L.M. Montgomery is not only guilty as charged but loves words to the point of obsession. She’s a verbosity monster, a chatterbox who can crank out the pages and soar on flights of fancy. She starts the Story Club, and writes sentences like these: “Cordelia was a regal brunette with a coronet of midnight hair and duskly flashing eyes. Geraldine was a queenly blonde with hair like spun gold and velvety purple eyes.” Go on with your bad self, Anne. Purple prose is your thing.
-
GWW girls carry incandescent minds, their heads roiling with raucous poetry and momentous thoughts. Sometimes they just need the right invitation to say their piece. I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings is Maya Angelou’s memoir, a survivor’s tale. When Mrs. Flowers mentors young Maya with books, tea, and vanilla cookies, the rusty lock on Maya’s mouth cracks open. The voice that abuse snuffed rekindles. The beauty stuffed in there so long finds kinship in Dickens and Beowulf and poetry recitations.
-
GWW girls are rough around the edges—even prickly to the point of pain. They bare and share without the filter that Ms. Manners insists keeps us civilized. Gilly of The Great Gilly Hopkins by Katherine Paterson is a nasty soul practiced in the art of manipulation when foster care dumps her out on Trotter’s doorstep. With her first dose of unconditional love, Gilly’s harshness softens, and her meanness and racism dissipates. Trotter, Mr. Randolph, and Miss Harris embrace Gilly’s sharp mind ready for integrity and real relationship, turning it to better things.
-
GWW girls ask the tough questions and ruminate till their brain hurts. Margaret in Are You There, God? It’s Me, Margaret by Judy Blume takes up the quest of her spiritual identity—am I Christian? Am I Jewish?—that is so much more than the book’s frequently known synopsis of must-must-increase-our-bust. The diary full of unanswerable questions shows her ability to face questions many adults dodge. Her poignant escape from the Catholic confessional captures our confusion in the face of the ineffable.
-
GWW girls are resilient in hard times. Laura Ingalls of the Little House on the Prairie series can hunker down as she does in The Long Winter, her memoir of surviving multiple blizzards in the winter of 1880-1881. Living on potatoes and coarse bread, warmed barely by twisted sticks of straw—Laura and her family gut it out for several months and barely escape starvation. Ingalls Wilder’s concise, uncomplaining prose accepts things as they are while Laura’s irrepressible spirit keeps asking, sassing, and challenging, showing her survivor genes the frontier demands.
-
GWW girls are critical know-it-alls. Felicia of Felicia the Critic by Ellen Conford has a knack for pointing out the truths no one else wants to see. She’s eager to advise, analyze, and nitpick. In the face of rejection, she vows to seal her lips, but discovers that muting a keen, deliberative mind doesn’t help anyone. Her discovery of the art of constructive critique is a great training ground for any GWW maiden.
-
GWW girls keep their heads in books and capture everyone else’s stories. Cassandra Mortmain of I Capture the Castle by Dodie Smith turns to her literary heroines and journal, a haven when she feels lost or insecure, whenever her eccentric family’s shenanigans become too much for her. Cassandra’s moral dilemma when romance strikes, pitting her versus her sister, shows her to rise to the occasion with not only intellectual but also emotional intelligence.
-
GWW girls are obsessed with history—not just facts, but getting the soul behind the story. April in The Egypt Game by Zilpha Keatley Snyder orchestrates a recreation of ancient Egyptian rituals with an eclectic group of friends—more multicultural than many of today’s YA landscapes—and persists in scavenging out the truths hidden in the Professor’s A-Z Antiques storage yard. April’s unquenchable desire to excavate makes her a quirky Indiana Jones before Hollywood discovered him.
-
GWW girls can’t stop writing the truth. Anne Frank whose journal became The Diary of Anne Frank is known for representing the resistance against Nazi Germany’s Holocaust, but we remember her for telling all about her body, her fears, her passions, and the foibles of her family trapped with the equally flawed Van Daans. Anne’s unflinching gaze at herself and others is the courageous act in the midst of all the waiting.
-
GWW girls strive to learn no matter where they’re planted, even if it’s in concrete. Francie in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith struggles like a weed through the cracks of sidewalk, finding joy in reading despite a bitter mother, an alcoholic father, and oppressive poverty. No matter what the circumstances, the dream to know more and better oneself is the Tree of Heaven in her heart.
There were many other books I read and re-read as a child: The Empty Schoolhouse; Mara, Daughter of the Nile; The Pistachio Prescription; The Story Girl; What Katy Did in School; Ballet Shoes for Anna…but I digress. I invite you to check out your library and recall the girls who inspired your inner nerd-dom. They gift us with a rallying cry of weirdness, they inspire us with their wisdom, and they never fail to surprise.
Lyn Fairchild Hawks is the author of a YA novel, How Wendy Redbird Dancing Survived the Dark Ages of Nought, and a collection of short stories, The Flat and Weightless Tang-Filled Future. She is also author of several works for English educators. You can find Lyn on Facebook, Twitter, and Goodreads.
Lyn is giving away a copy of How Wendy Redbird Dancing Survived the Dark Ages of Nought. Click here to see the trailer and here to be part of the Rafflecopter giveaway she is hosting.
So many books on this list brought me back to my childhood!!! I call so many of these titles favorites! Thank you for introducing me to some new friends and for reminding me about old friends. Can’t wait to add some of these to my TBR list!
I really think that it was a great idea for you to start making books with this very interesting theme. As looking at the books, I have never read anyone of these but now I want to. Some of the characters in the book I can relate to when I was once a child. I most definitely will have these book as apart of my list to read. I like how the books address social issues that a lot of young girls are facing now. I actually sat here and read each summary about each book and it really excited me to want to read more and even tell some of my friends about them.
I totally agree. I would show my future students and friends some of these books. The titles seems very interesting and makes me anxious to read! I probably could most definitely relate to some or most of these books.
Love this! I recently wrote a similar post for librarian Sarah Thompson about middle-grade titles with strong heroines, (http://www.greenbeanteenqueen.com/2013/11/so-you-want-to-read-middle-grade.html) and we’ve got a lot of overlap: Laura, Anne, Gilly.
LOVE that Maya Angelou made the list. I think of her as a child, riding that train across country with nothing but a tag on her dress to show where she was to go. So brave. And Francie Nolan, who if she’d been a real girl would have been my friend. I CAPTURE THE CASTLE was something I discovered maybe ten years ago and have pushed on as many people as would listen to me.
I really think that it was a great idea for you to start making books with this very interesting theme. As looking at the books, I have never read anyone of these but now I want to. Some of the characters in the book I can relate to when I was once a child. I most definitely will have these book as apart of my list to read. I like how the books address social issues that a lot of young girls are facing now. I actually sat here and read each summary about each book and it really excited me to want to read more and even tell some of my friends about them.
I really think that it was a great idea for you to start making books with this very interesting theme. As looking at the books, I have never read anyone of these but now I want to. Some of the characters in the book I can relate to when I was once a child. I most definitely will have these book as apart of my list to read. I like how the books address social issues that a lot of young girls are facing now. I actually sat here and read each summary about each book and it really excited me to want to read more and even tell some of my friends about them.
Thanks, Kimberly. (I am finally getting the hang of this site so I’m behind on comments/replies.) The social issues of yesterday still persist, don’t they? I think it does help young women and girls see that girls in 1970 and 1900 worried about some of the things that plague us today. Sibling rivalry, questions about God, questions about sexuality, jealousy and regret over friendships…Signs of timeless works!
You are welcome! Like I stated before I am very happy that you started this blog. Yes indeed, the social issues of yesterday still persist! There is a big difference between the way girls are living now from the 1900s. What way to learn about those differences is through books. My generation which is 1990s, the girls in it obviously has no clue what a lot of the girls in the 1930s or 1970s went through. A lot of people see the world differently and I am just really excited to start reading the list of books that are listed above! There are a lot of social issues that most likely will always seem to exist but we can do things to get people attention about these social issues and try to come up with solutions. But most importantly give the people a chance to want to read the books listed above. If you explain to a middle school student what the books are about and how they can help them with their social issues so Im pretty sure they will want to read them. Just give them a good reasons to. This will help upcoming teachers such as myself to want to have some of the books on my shelf in my classroom.
Fantastic post! Made me wish that you and I could have met as middle schoolers. We would have been great friends!
I totally agree! I believe we would have! I am just ready to start reading the books! I feel I would really love the books and maybe even tell my reading and writing teacher about the list because she loves to read all kinds of books and always stress to us how important it is to read. So I might most definitely tell her about this.
This is quite a diverse list! I’ve only read a few of them, but have been made curious about the others! Thanks 🙂
Thanks for everyone’s kind words. This was so fun to do…and also somewhat heart rending…leaving out wonderful girls always hurts. 🙂 Caroline Starr Rose, thanks for your list…I see a whole bunch of strong girls I want to check out now! I forgot about the image of Maya on the train…
Cheryl, agreed! We would have hung out and been “nerds” and “brains” together, when we weren’t reading, that is!
Lyn
So what do you think of the ones you have read so far? Were they attention getters as soon as you read them? Maybe you can give me a little insight on how they are lol before I start reading the books. Are you curious about how the other books are going to turn out or you just anxious to start reading them?
Oh, Kimberly, is THAT why you and Brittany asked ME these questions?! LOL Oh, that’s too funny! This is not my blog! I simply posted a comment on it. My blogs are not launched yet, but you CAN follow them (if they look interesting to you) so you’ll know once they’re up and running! lol
http://www.writersideup.com
and
http://www.2creativitycookbook.com
Happy Reading 🙂
Donna
What few have you read? Could you relate to the few you’ve read so far? Do you enjoy reading books with illustrations?
Kimberly and Brittany, you’re so sweet to ask. I didn’t think what I read, etc. mattered, and hadn’t thought to get into lengthy discussion about it! lol But, since you asked:
Quite a few years back (maybe 8 or 10?) I read ANNE OF GREEN GABLES. A friend had made me aware of the WONderful PBS movies (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0088727/?ref_=fn_al_tt_1). I fell in love with the characters and story, so eventually read the book and loved it 🙂 Anne is inescapably endearing, and as a character she truly grows and changes.
I own I KNOW WHY THE CAGED BIRD SINGS and THE GREAT GILLY HOPKINS, but have yet to read either, so these summaries sparked my interest again.
I also own LITTLE HOUSE IN THE BIG WOODS (one from the “Little House on the Prairie” series). I read it about half way through, but it started becoming tedious and boring to me as I was reading (the beginning was wonderful) so I put it aside 😦
For the longest time, I’ve wanted to read THE DIARY OF ANNE FRANK and A TREE GROWS IN BROOKLYN. I’ve seen the “Diary” movie several times and love it so much. I would love to read it and hear the story first hand. And I saw a small piece of the “Tree” movie and that intrigues me, much for the same reason: the voice of the protagonist, and character-rich.
For the longest time I’ve been aware of ARE YOU THERE, GOD? IT’S ME MARGARET. The fact that it’s a Judy Blume book, and the title itself compel me, I’ve yet to make a point of reading it.
The few other titles I’d never heard of, but the variety of protagonists spark curiosity.
Of course, like any book lover, my to-read list is MUCH longer than my life allows and every time I finish reading a book, I struggle picking which one of the many I should read next, and these include from books I actually own, and others that come recommended that I get through the library. It’s an ongoing dilemma! And now that I’m finally active with social media and reading blogs (such as this wonderful one), I have barely any tiime for reading books or doing much of anything else! lol I MUST get a handle on all of it! 😀
Wow! Well, I really appreciate this. I understand what you mean. I hardly have anytime to read any of the books that I want to read. It is very good that own some books. I am trying to start my collections as we speak. I also struggle trying to figure out which books to rad next because I loved a lot of themes and I want to read them all but we all know that is impossible (maybe) lol. I have read THE DIARY OF ANNE FRANK and it is really a good book. You should read that book first. I believe I have also read or heard of I KNOW WHY THE CAGED BIRD SINGS but Im not sure. I am really learning a lot about your blog and very excited that you started this blog. Keep up the good work! 🙂
Yeah I figured that out yesterday @writerssideup lol! But I will sure to look at your blog as well!
Hi, everyone,
My post didn’t go through earlier, so I’ll try again. I really enjoyed reading everyone’s comments and seeing which ones people have read. I love the passionate, voracious reading community here. Caroline Starr Rose–your image of Maya Angelou I had forgotten about, and it is such a compelling one. Nerdy Book Club is a great space and I am glad it’s here.
Lyn
Love that Anne of Green Gables made this list…and that you gave a shout out to so many other books I loved growing up that I never knew anyone else who’d read–Mara, the Katy books, the Story Girl….I feel just like when I was a kid and found someone loved the books I did.I want to come over to browse your bookshelf.
Thanks, Natasha! Sounds as if we had the same tastes! I can still see the place in my grade school library where I discovered Mara, Daughter of the Nile…and how many times did I check that same book out? Did you re-read the same books at least 10 times? I wish I could do that now…My mom keeps a bookshelf in her house of all my old-school girl books…a bit of a shrine. 🙂 By the way, L.M. Montgomery’s biography is fascinating if you ever get to read it…a whole new insight into Anne.
These are amazing choices–ALL favorites from my youth! So fun to be reminded of them!