Tags
Some Books for Now and Some Books for Later by Donalyn Miller
I learned to read at a young age, and my parents soon lost the ability or will to monitor my reading choices. They trusted me to find books and navigate the ideas in what I read with little parental oversight. Occasionally, I would ask my mom about specific words or scenes that I didn’t understand, but I approached most books at whatever access point I was ready to approach them.
In middle school, I read a lot of Stephen King. It was the 80’s. King’s books and stories were made into successful movies like The Shining and Creepshow, and King was a popular cultural figure. Beyond the violence—which was expected—King’s books had a lot of sex, drinking, and cussing in them. I regularly gave myself nightmares falling asleep while reading books like Cujo and ‘Salem’s Lot. For almost a year, I wide-stepped from my bedroom doorway to my bed each night—afraid of what lurked underneath.
You might have suggested that I read something more suitable for my age, but I didn’t know any young adult authors beyond S.E. Hinton. Like many of my peers, I jumped from children’s books to adult books. I don’t remember a librarian or teacher every talking to my parents about the books I read. No one thought my reading choices were strange or inappropriate.
Reading adult books outside of school wasn’t that different from what we read in school. The texts we read in English class were written for adults, too—To Kill a Mockingbird, Daniel Keyes’ Flowers for Algernon, The Autobiography of Miss Jane Pittman by Ernest Gaines, and scores of short stories, poems, and plays. Classroom discussions about these texts reinforced that reading serious works helped prepare us for our adult lives. We were unsophisticated, unruly teens, but reading would civilize us. If a parent complained about the texts we read at school, my classmates and I never knew about it. Teachers determined what texts we read.
Undoubtedly, I read books during my childhood that I wasn’t ready to read. I read books that bothered me. I read books that exposed me to mature behaviors and ideas. I read some books that I didn’t really understand. When I talk with other adult readers, we all remember books that we shouldn’t have been reading, but passed along to our friends like contraband. We joke about hiding V.C. Andrews’ Flowers in the Attic in our closets and recall sneak reading Go Ask Alice in between the covers of our history textbooks. We know that lots of free-range, unmonitored, less-than-literary reading experiences during childhood helped us keep reading into adulthood. There’s room in a reading life for Flowers for Algernon and Flowers in the Attic. As Neil Gaiman says, “Read. Read anything. Read the things they say are good for you, and the things they claim are junk. You’ll find what you need to find. Just read.”
If you want your children to read for a lifetime, you must accept their questionable book choices from time-to-time. When we control children’s reading diet or communicate disdain or fear for their choices, children are unlikely to find reading personally meaningful or enjoyable. On the other hand, we cannot knowingly expose children to themes and situations beyond their emotional and intellectual development. As adult reading mentors, we walk a thin line between encouraging children’s reading choices and supervising access to mature content.
Parents have the last word in whether their children can read a specific book or not, and we must respect individual families’ boundaries for book selection. As a teacher, parents have communicated their concerns about what their children should or shouldn’t read over the years. I’m always respectful in these conversations whether I agree or not. As long as parents don’t claim jurisdiction over the book access or reading choices of other people’s children, I support their points of view. If a parent doesn’t want their child to read a particular book, there’s always another book to offer.
When teachers or administrators require all students in a class or grade level to read a specific text, however, book selection becomes more challenging to navigate. I think we paint ourselves into a corner when we assign controversial or edgy text to our students without considering potential objections to a book. Someone is going to complain sooner or later. Evaluating a book through our personal lens doesn’t value our students or their families’ belief systems. We shouldn’t self-censor our classrooms and libraries because we fear complaints or questions, but we should be smart about it. One size does not fit all. Individual children may be ready to read texts with more violence, sexual content, or adult themes, but this doesn’t mean everyone in a class is ready. Some suggestions for using controversial texts in the classroom:
- Read every text you require your students to read. It doesn’t matter that your department chair or curriculum director approved a book when parents start calling you. Reread it every year and consider your current students’ perspectives and needs. Several high profile censorship cases in recent years involved episodes where teachers assigned books they hadn’t read and were caught off-guard by upset parents. Administrators should know about any potentially controversial texts required by your district or classroom teachers, too.
- Read professional reviews and publisher’s guidelines for any books you consider for required reading, and follow credible advice about age-appropriateness. Buzzwords like “rigorous” and “complex” don’t give you carte blanche to assign middle school books to elementary kids.
- Research your district or school’s book selection policies. If you don’t have a policy, work with your administrators, community members, and colleagues to create one. Strong policies consider diversity, age-appropriateness, literary merit, and reading appeal. Discuss differences between books promoted and offered for independent reading and those assigned as required texts.
- Send a letter or e-mail home to families explaining your book selection policies and why specific books were chosen for all children to read. I suggest Kate Messner’s Heading Off Book Challenges letter as a guide.
- Identify controversial language and themes and determine IN ADVANCE how to address questions or concerns about a book’s content. If you cannot justify a book’s value as a required text, consider alternative choices.
- Don’t assume that because a book is a “classic” you are in the clear. Canonical texts like J.D. Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye and John Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men regularly receive challenges from local communities.
- Don’t assume a book is OK because it was made into an age-appropriate movie or TV show. In order to secure PG and PG-13 ratings, screenwriters and directors often alter scenes and dialogue from mature content books like The Perks of Being a Wallflower and The Fault in Our Stars.
- Consider whether reading a particular text best serves your curriculum and students. Offering readers choice from thematic texts sets, topical lists, or genre studies differentiates for students’ needs, preferences, and experiences while meeting curricular goals.
There’s a difference between the books children choose to read and the books we choose for them. There’s a difference between adding a book to our library and adding it to our syllabus. Some books are for now and some books are for later. As Kristine Mraz says, “When we are selecting which books to read in the classroom (and library), we are making ethical choices.” The text we require students to read should value their emotional needs and family mores to the degree possible.
Please share your experiences and thoughts about this topic. We can all learn from each other.
Donalyn Miller has taught fourth, fifth, and sixth grade English and Social Studies in Northeast Texas. She is the author of two books about encouraging students to read, The Book Whisperer (Jossey-Bass, 2009) and Reading in the Wild (Jossey-Bass, 2013). Donalyn co-hosts the monthly Twitter chat, #titletalk (with Nerdy Book Club co-founder, Colby Sharp) and the Best Practices Roots (#bproots) chat with Teri Lesesne. Donalyn launched the annual Twitter summer and holiday reading initiative, #bookaday. You can find her on Twitter at @donalynbooks or under a pile of books somewhere, happily reading.
Wonderful post.
I’m so glad that my teenagers have a wealth of YA material to choose from.
Flowers In The Attic and Go Ask Alice both left scars!
I moved rapidly on to Maeve Binchy.
This brought back memories from my reading journey, especially your authors. I scared myself so often with King and Koontz. As a teacher, I love the choices for readers now. Wonderful!!!
This is so true. I read prett much whatever I wanted as a child for many of the same reasons…I had outgrown the Babysitter’s Club and moved onto Judy Blume & then my mom’s Danielle Steele books! Thankfully (?) I wasn’t part of a school that assigned novels as a part of curriculum…only the textbooks (far too much Shakespeare!) it was a bit of a shock when my 8th grader came home from his new school with The Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian. Wow. I had serious concerns but felt like I’d be a hypocrite for addressing them since I’m all about not ‘banning’ books and freedom of book choice. I had to really take a step back. I still have concerns about what his teacher is assigning & her ‘why’ (she LOVES YA and thinks ‘edgy’ books will get them all to love reading…Nevermind those who already do) anyway… Long reply to say that this is excellent as always Donalyn. You are so insightful and have something for everyone involved, be they administrator, teacher, librarian, or parent. 🙂
Finding the “right book” for my above level 5th & 6th grade readers is always a challenge. I know they can handle to complex text, but are not ready for the complex topics and language. Even with the wealth of YA material out there, it is still difficult. I, on the other hand, as a 6th/7th grader read many books I probably shouldn’t have read, but all is good. Those “forbidden” books helped me know what genres I most enjoy today (or don’t enjoy, i.e. Stephen King. LOL) Thanks for the great post!!
I read far too many books set in concentration camps when I was around 11 years old. Cast a pall over me for a while that was hard to dispel.
Reblogged this on Mayor of Bookopolis.
This is so wise, Donalyn. My 4th grade team recently experienced significant parent concern when we wanted to read aloud George as a whole grade novel. We quickly assessed the situation and changed plans slightly. We chose a different whole grade novel to read aloud and offered George and Fish in a Tree as two read aloud book clubs dealing with Identity and Difference (with parent selection for each child). We’re happy to preserve our read aloud community building with a different book; we still get to address the themes we desire; the kids get more read aloud time, so they’re over the moon; and parent concern is adequately addressed. It’s a win-win-win!
This sounds like a great solution that values families and the reading choices of kids!
I place what I personally consider to be mature for grade level books in a separate bin that is subtly titled “tough topics.” I don’t draw attention to the bin and don’t book talk from the bin, but I do watch who figures out what the bin is for and who takes books from it.
^to add: My personal reading threshold is very, very “PG,” so I have a hard time knowing what might be a little mature for grade level. I also cross-check professional reviews, our school library collections, and sources like commonsensemedia.org for a general sense of appropriateness.
I had a shelf of more mature MS titles for my 6th graders that I selectively loaned to specific kids after I determined their abilities and talked with parents.
So funny that Flowers in the Attic binds together a generation of readers. I did not have any awareness of YA books when I was a child either. I am thankful for all the books that are available for people to read these days. With that being said, and looking at the idea that some books are for now and some books are for later, a teacher has to have read the books to know which are which.
Agreed!
Thank you for posting this Donalyn! As a middle school English Department head, this is a topic I struggle with quite a bit. We have choice reading at our school, and teachers struggle to purchase and keep classroom libraries with excellent choices for children. We also have several whole class novels we teach.
For these novels, we send a letter home, explaining sensitive issues and occasionally a parent will request that their child read a different book. We handle this by setting up independent reading with reflections on a google doc. The teacher invites the child to stay for the mini-lesson and then sends them to the library for their independent part.
I do worry about the child who may take a book from our classroom library and find that it is too mature for them. Thank you for sharing Kate’s letter. I think we will send something like that home next year.
There are so many wonderful stories, but YA and controversial can be synonymous! I recently read an amazing story about friendship and standing up for yourself — Lilly and Dunkin by Donna Gephart. It also explores being transgender and bipolar in middle school. While this is a essential book for some students, it may not be welcomed by some families. So, it is a delicate balance between matching book, child, and family. I guess it comes down to communication and relationships. I guess it comes down to knowing your students and their families as the best way to support young readers developing into adult readers.
I really enjoyed your post. Like you I read whatever I wanted. My mom even checked out books from the adult section for me because there was a rule in place that you had to be a certain age to read these titles.
My favorite memory was reading The Godfather in senior English class (1970). Obviously the teacher hadn’t read it before assigning it. Wow!
It isn’t easy is it?!
So true! I can’t imagine my kids reading the things I got my hands on back then. Flowers in the Attic is always disappearing at my library…
I agree in so many ways. I rate books on Goodreads (which even former students have access to at any time to get suggestions from), and I always post if the book has language or sexual content, just as an FYI. Some kids are ready for it, and some parents are fine with it. Some fantastic books have “sensitive materials” in them. We do not want to keep kids from books, but we have to be careful also. I have always had a wide variety of books I “push” at kids to be able to reach them all. You have great tips for teachers to navigate those waters. Thanks! I was also pretty free to read what I wanted as a kid because I read so much. I admitted to my mother later I read one on her “forbidden list” (I think it really only had one book on it), and she just shook her head at me when I admitted I totally should NOT have read it because it was an awful book for me. haha Oh, kids!
I’m appreciative of this post too as I teach 4/5th graders who are in the HCC (highly capable cohort) and read at the 8th grade level and beyond. I’m looking for lists of newer titles that are age appropriate. It’s not easy. I’m an avid YA reader, but some of it is so edgy, it’s not going to fly with parents. anyone have a list going?